If a Rental Unit Is Not Ready On Move-In Day, Can the Landlord Be Held Responsible?

The Residential Tenancies Act, 2006 Prescribes a Duty Upon a Landlord to Provide a Fit For Occupancy Rental Unit By the Scheduled Move-In Day Failing Which the Landlord May Be Liable. This Mandate Remains Even If the Tenant Knew and Agreed That Readiness Would Be Delayed.

Similar Questions About Delayed Occupancy Issues Include:

  • Can a Landlord Reschedule a Move-In Day If Renovations Need More Time?
  • What Happens If An Apartment Is Not Ready On Move-In Day?
  • Is a Landlord Allowed to Delay the Move-In Day If Renovations Are Delayed?
  • Can An Occupancy Date Be Legally Delayed Due to Ongoing Renovations?
  • If the Landlord Fails to Have a Rental Unit Ready For Move In Day What Happens?


A Helpful Guide For How to Determine and Understand the Duty Upon a Landlord to Ensure Availability of a Habitable Rental Unit

Residential Tenancy Lease Document Sometimes a landlord and tenant will enter into a tenancy agreement during the course of construction, renovation, repair, or other readiness preparations, for the intended rental unit.  While entering into a tenancy agreement prior to readiness of the rental unit is permitted, doing so may lead to difficulties for the landlord whereas, potentially troublesome for the landlord, section 20 of the Residential Tenancies Act, 2006S.O. 2006, Chapter 17, prescribes an absolute duty to provide a habitable rental unit on the scheduled occupancy (move-in) date.  The Residential Tenancies Act, 2006 explicitly states:

Landlord’s Responsibility to Repair

20 (1) A landlord is responsible for providing and maintaining a residential complex, including the rental units in it, in a good state of repair and fit for habitation and for complying with health, safety, housing and maintenance standards.

Same

(2) Subsection (1) applies even if the tenant was aware of a state of non-repair or a contravention of a standard before entering into the tenancy agreement.

Per section 20 (2) as above, the mandate of section 20 (1) applies even if the tenant was aware of the unfit state of repair; and accordingly, even if the tenant knew that the rental unit would be unfit for habitat on move-in day, such as where a status update or other notice was provided to the tenant in advance of the move-in day, the landlord remains obligated to provide the unit in a fit state of repair and the failure to do so is a default upon the landlord.  Furthermore, the tenant and landlord are unable to waive or agree to waive, the default whereas section 4 of the the Residential Tenancies Act, 2006 voids any such agreements as may conflict with the Residential Tenancies Act, 2006.

All of the above was deemed so by the Divisional Court within the case of Swan v. Liang, 2019 ONSC 1573, as an Appeal from a Landlord Tenant Board decision and wherein it was said:

[17]  The Board made a number of errors of law.  First, in its disposal of the application, the Board improperly fixated on the notion that the tenant knew of the deficiencies from his visit on April 4 and failed to consult his wife before entering into the lease.  The Board improperly considered the tenant’s knowledge of the state of the unit prior to taking possession.  Subsections 20(1) and (2) of the Residential Tenancies Act clearly indicate that the landlord is responsible to ensure that a residence is fit for habitation and in good state of repair from the outset of the tenancy.  Subsection 20(2) makes it clear that the landlord is not relieved of this obligation, even if the tenant knows that a state of non-repair exists when the lease is first entered into.

As such, when a landlord enters into a lease with a tenant, even where the tenant may come to know, or even agree, that the rental unit will lack readiness on the move-in date, the obligation upon the landlord to provide a ready and fit unit remains regardless.

Available Remedies

Upon a finding that the landlord failed to meet the obligations to provide a unit fit for habitation as required by section 20 of the Residential Tenancies Act, 2006, the statutorily available remedies are prescribed in section 29 of the Residential Tenancies Act, 2006.  The available remedies include an abatement of rent, potentially up to one hundred (100%) percent, as well as reimbursement to the tenant for reasonably necessary expenses incurred by the tenant as a consequence of the lack of readiness of the rental unit such as the cost of temporary accommodations, temporary storage, among other things.  Indeed, these were the remedies awarded by the Divisional Court within the Swan case where it was said:

[28]  Given the finding that the house was not fit for habitation and the parties’ agreement that the tenancy would be terminated, we are satisfied that the tenant is entitled to the return of his deposit and prepaid rent of $2,175. The landlord agreed that the last month’s rent should be returned.  The tenant was unable to use the premises safely pending the repairs (other than storage in the garage, for which he offered to pay $100).  The tenant should receive an abatement of the rent for April, given the finding and the clear evidence that the premises were not fit for habitation by the tenant and his family.

[29]  In addition, we are satisfied that the tenant is entitled to reimbursement for his hotel cost of $134.47 and utilities of $155.64  paid for this rental unit that he could not occupy, for a total of $290.11 for out-of-pocket expenses.  We acknowledge that the tenant was able to store some of his property on the premises for several weeks at a cost of $100, and we take this into consideration in determining the tenant’s entitlement to compensation.

[30]  We would not award any amount for the higher rent at the new premises.

Interestingly, per paragraph 30 in the Swan case, the Divisional Court declined to award compensation for the increased cost of a substitute rental unit obtained by Swan.

Summary Comment

When a landlord and tenant enter into a lease agreement in advance of the rental unit being ready for occupancy, the landlord takes on an absolute duty to provide a fit and habitable unit by the agreed upon occupancy (move-in) date.  The absolute duty is statutorily imposed upon the landlord and is without any leeway, even if the tenant were to agree to leeway.  Of course, a tenant that agrees to provide leeway may indeed forgo the right to pursue the landlord for failure to provide a ready unit; however, such a leeway agreement fails, in law, to negate the duty of the landlord.  If the tenant does pursue rights for remedy for the failure of the landlord to provide a ready unit, compensation in various forms may be available including the full abatement of rent paid or due, release from further obligations per the lease, the compensation for reasonably consequential expenses incurred by the tenant, among other things.


[Legal Firm's Name] provides affordable services for clients located in [Legal Firm's City], Kingston, Guelph, Barrie, Toronto, among other places!
Get a FREE ½ HOUR CONSULTATION

Do You Have a Case? Let's Get Started Today

ATTENTION: Do not send any confidential information through this website form.  Use this website form only for making an introduction.

For more information, fill out the form below to send a direct inquiry to Marketing.Legal

ATTENTION: Do not send any confidential information through this website form.  Use this website form only for making an introduction with a Marketing.Legal representative.
Marketing.Legal

86 Kersey Crescent
Courtice, Ontario,
L1E 0A4

P: (800) 551-5751
E: awesome@marketing.legal

Hours of Business:

10:00AM – 8:00PM
10:00AM – 8:00PM
10:00AM – 8:00PM
10:00AM – 8:00PM
10:00AM – 8:00PM
Monday:
Tuesday:
Wednesday:
Thursday:
Friday:

By appointment only.  Please call for details.







Serving:

Lawyers
Paralegals
Law Clerks
Process Servers
and more.

Questions?

We Offer a 
FREE ½ Hour Consultation

Marketing.Legal is a 100% Canadian brand, owned and operated incorporated business, with dedicated expert professionals, having decades of qualified experience in Website Development, Search Engine Optimization (SEO), Google Adwords, and Social Media marketing for Lawyers and Paralegals.


Marketing.Legal

SSL Secured
Trust https://marketing.legal


Animated Spinner